ASC substantiation Philippines: a first-pass approval checklist
ASC substantiation Philippines: the proof the Ad Standards Council expects for No. 1, absolute and comparative claims, as a pre-submission checklist.
Many ads that come back from the Ad Standards Council do not fail on creative. They fail on proof. Use this ASC substantiation Philippines checklist to match every claim in your ad to the specific document the ASC Code asks for, before you submit. It shows what counts as proof, what does not, and which claim types need more than one document.
Everything below comes from the ASC Code of Ethics and Standard Manual of Procedures, effective April 29, 2024. Where the Code leaves room for judgment, we say so. The screening committee has the final word, so treat this as preparation, not a guarantee.
ASC substantiation Philippines: why proof decides your timeline
The Code is plain about the baseline. Ads shall be honest, truthful and accurate. Ads shall not mislead by sweeping generalization, inaccuracy, ambiguity, exaggeration or omission. Any test or demonstration in an ad must be supported with proper documentation.
In practice, this means the screening committee reads your ad as a list of claims, then looks for a document behind each one. A missing document is the fastest route to a revision request. If you are new to the process, read how ASC screening works first, then come back to this checklist.
Step 1: List every claim in the ad
Before you collect a single document, write out every claim the ad makes. Include the ones that are easy to miss:
- Spoken lines in the voiceover and the dialogue
- Supers, on-screen text and end cards
- Packaging shown on screen, if the pack carries a claim
- Hashtags that carry a claim
- Visual demonstrations, such as a stain test or a before and after shot
- The brand name itself, if the name suggests a benefit
The hashtag and brand name items surprise teams most often. Both are covered later in this guide.
Step 2: Know which documents the ASC accepts
The Ad Standards Council Code lists the kinds of support documents it accepts. The list is not closed. Article V, Section 14 of the Code names these:
- Quantitative consumer research. Qualitative research is not accepted as claim support, because the Code treats it as only indicative.
- Volume and value retail or home panel audit data.
- Published journals.
- Clinical or laboratory tests.
- Company certification signed by a VP level or higher.
- Notarized endorsements.
- Product Information Leaflet for over-the-counter drugs.
- Packaging for food supplements and other CFRR-registered products.
Articles downloaded from the internet are generally accepted, provided they have been published. A screenshot of a blog post with no publication record is a weak bet.
The most common mistake here is focus group findings. A focus group tells you how people feel. It does not prove a claim, and the Code says so directly.
Step 3: Match the claim type to its proof standard
The Code sets different standards for different claim types. Several of these are must-screen claims, and each one has its own rule.
No. 1 or leadership claims
A No. 1 claim means leadership in both retail sales volume and its monetary value, in the total category or a generally accepted segment. Your checklist:
- At least the last 12 months of cumulative data, covering both volume and value
- Data from an independent source acceptable to the ASC
- For a national claim, coverage of at least two provinces in each of North and Central Luzon, South Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao, plus one key city for each of the North, South, East and West areas of Metro Manila
- If the claim covers only certain areas, the ad must state those areas prominently
- The product must have a competitor. A product with no competitor cannot claim No. 1
A No. 1 approval is not permanent. If a competitor shows that its volume and value data for the last 6 months puts it ahead, the ASC can issue a Cease-and-Desist Order against the approved claim. The challenger still needs its own 12 months of data to claim No. 1.
Some categories have no volume and value reading. For these, the Code allows industry-accepted support subject to ASC validation, plus a certification from a high-ranking official (VP, Director and up) explaining why the data does not exist. Service categories that volume and value cannot measure can use category-accepted standards.
Absolute claims
Absolute claims are words like guaranteed, sure, 100% and always. The Code requires at least three separate but identical tests by an independent third-party testing agency, using the same method, within 12 months.
- One agency doing all three tests: at least one month between each test
- Three different agencies: the tests can run at the same time, with the same method and protocol
Adding the word helps does not soften an absolute claim. The Code says helps or its equivalent cannot be used to get around the absolute claim rule.
Comparative claims
Any comparison with a competing product needs clear, verifiable support from an independent third-party source. The claim must also say what it compares against, for example vs another brand or vs previous formulation.
- Indirect comparison. Allowed if the ad uses no element that points to a specific competitor, such as colors, symbols, slogans or sound cues. If the link is disputed, a third-party consumer study is used to prove it.
- Vs previous formulation. Needs third-party lab tests, clinical studies or consumer studies, and the qualifier can be used for one year from the last formulation change.
- Direct or branded comparison. Allowed only in categories with measurable technical benchmarks: automotive vehicles (not products like lubricants), consumer durables, airline aircraft and shipping lines' ships, musical instruments and entertainment devices, and mobile products such as handsets, tablets and laptops.
We cover this area in more depth in comparative advertising in the Philippines.
Exclusivity and parity claims
Exclusivity claims, such as the only shampoo with a given fragrance, need third-party support. Parity claims, such as nothing beats Brand L, do not claim an advantage, but the Code still requires substantiation and a qualifier where needed.
Ingredient claims
Two rules apply. First, the ingredient's quantity and properties must be verified and must follow applicable law. Second, a benefit can only be claimed if the whole product delivers it, not only the active ingredient. If your ad says an ingredient causes a benefit, you need proof of a verifiable cause and effect link.
Before and after visuals
Before and after comparisons must be truthful and not exaggerated, and the ad must state the time that passed between the two shots, with prominence. See before and after skincare rules for category examples.
Step 4: Check the claims you did not know were claims
Hashtags
An unbranded hashtag used without any branded post or brand asset does not need pre-screening. A hashtag that carries a must-screen claim (No. 1 or leadership, absolute, comparative, exclusivity or superiority) does. When a branded ad with claim-bearing hashtags goes to the ASC, those hashtag claims need substantiation too.
Suggestive brand names
A brand name like Real Juice or True-Milk cannot serve as a product claim unless evidence other than the name supports it. If the name implies a benefit and the ad leans on the benefit, prepare proof as if the name were a line of copy.
Qualifiers on screen
The Code names specific qualifiers and when they apply:
- Vs non-use is not needed when comparing against not using the product. Categories with high penetration cannot use it.
- Serving suggestion is needed when the product is shown with extras it does not contain as packed, such as vegetables added to instant noodles.
- Creative visualization is needed when the ad shows product action the naked eye cannot see, such as molecules at work.
The ASC substantiation checklist before you submit
Run this list against your final cut, not the storyboard:
- Every claim in voiceover, supers, packs and hashtags is listed.
- Each claim has a named claim type: general, No. 1, absolute, comparative, exclusivity, parity or ingredient.
- Each claim has a document from the accepted list, and none of the support is qualitative research.
- No. 1 claims carry 12 months of volume and value data with the required area coverage.
- Absolute claims carry three identical third-party tests inside 12 months.
- Comparative claims carry third-party data and a visible qualifier.
- Before and after visuals state the time elapsed.
- Required qualifiers (serving suggestion, creative visualization) are on screen.
- The brand name does not make a claim the evidence cannot back.
- Internet sources are published articles, not unpublished pages.
For the rest of the submission package, pair this with our ASC submission checklist and the list of common ASC violations.
Build the proof before the concept
The Ad Standards Council of the Philippines reviews the ad you submit, not the brief behind it. If the evidence arrives after the creative, the creative usually changes. Agree on the claims with the brand team first, collect the documents, then write. The order costs a few days at the start and saves a rework after the committee responds.
AdScan checks your ad against these substantiation rules before you submit. Upload your next ad and see which claims need proof before the screening committee does.
Related ASC guides
- What ASC clearance actually means (and what happens without it)
- How to get ASC approval: the screening process step by step
- The ASC submission checklist for first-time advertisers
- The 12 most common ASC violations — and how to avoid them
- The ASC Code of Ethics, explained for Philippine marketers
- What ASC screening actually costs in 2026
Take it to the work
Want this checked before you submit?
Upload your ad to AdScan and get a report on likely ASC issues in seconds. First two scans are free.
Get 2 free scans